The Best of the Definitive American Songbook, Vol. 2: I-Z sets out to compile great performances of songs written in the 1920s through the 1950s by American songwriters both legendary (like
Johnny Mercer,
Hoagy Carmichael,
George and
Ira Gershwin,
Billy Strayhorn and
Duke Ellington, and
Harold Arlen) and obscure (like
Jack Lawrence,
Walter Gross,
Harry Link,
Jack Strachey, and
Holt Marvell). The "I-Z" refers to the titles of the songs; the disc travels from "It Had to Be You" (written by
Gus Kahn and
Isham Jones and sung by
Kay Starr) to "Where or When" (written by
Rodgers & Hart and sung by
Dick Haymes). In between are performances by such titans as
Dean Martin (
Lerner & Loewe's "On the Street Where You Live"),
Peggy Lee (
Cole Porter's "Just One of Those Things"), and
Ella Fitzgerald (
Billy Rose,
E.Y. Harburg, and
Harold Arlen's "It's Only a Paper Moon"). There are also some definitive performances, like
Chet Baker's breathtaking take on
Rodgers & Hart's "My Funny Valentine,"
Louis Prima and
Keely Smith's knockout version of
Johnny Mercer and
Harold Arlen's "That Old Black Magic," and
Lena Horne's version of
Harold Arlen and
Ted Koehler's "Stormy Weather." The collection is a top-notch blend of wonderful songs and sterling vocal talent; the only missteps are the inclusion of two songs recorded in the 1980s:
Rosemary Clooney's bland-sounding take on
Jack Lawrence and
Walter Gross' "Tenderly" from 1980 and
Linda Ronstadt's pallid version of
the Gershwins' "Someone to Watch Over Me." There are eight more volumes of the series set to be released; if they are all as good as the first two you should start clearing shelf space now.
–
Tim Sendra, Rovi